Politics Research · Labor & Political Money
← Newsroom
Union political spending · Research findings

Union political spending: results from ballot measures, bills, and elections

Union-backed sides won 33 of 49 decided ballot measures in 12 states, where Civly traced $175.4M in union ballot-measure spending. Funded legislators sponsored 4.2× as many pro-labor bills as unfunded colleagues in the same party. Those bills passed at 57.6%, compared with 56.5% for pro-labor bills from unfunded colleagues. Floor votes differed by about 2 points across 55 within-party comparisons, and close-election results for 5,361 candidates varied by state.

By · Chief Technology Officer, Civly ·
Union ballot-measure money traced
$175.4M
Measures their side won
33 of 49
Pro-labor bills sponsored, funded vs unfunded
4.2×
Within-party voting difference
About 2 points
The scorecard

Five outcomes examined

Observed
Ballot-measure wins

Union-backed sides won 33 of 49 decided measures. The dataset covers 54 committees and $175.4M of union money across 12 states from 2014 to 2025.

Observed
Pro-labor bill sponsorship

Funded legislators sponsored 4.2× as many pro-labor bills as their unfunded colleagues, compared with 1.4× as many bills overall.

Small difference
Bill passage

Pro-labor bills from funded legislators passed at 57.6%, compared with 56.5% for bills from unfunded legislators.

Small difference
Floor voting

Funded legislators sided with labor on final passage about 2 points more often across 55 within-party comparisons, with a range of −5.0 to +18.1.

Not established
Close-election wins

We matched 5,361 candidates across six states. Close-race win-rate differences ranged from −0.5 to +42 points, with the largest differences in the smallest samples.

Ballot measures

Union-backed sides won 33 of 49 measures

54 committees campaigning on named ballot measures in twelve states received $175.4M in union contributions from 2014 onward. 49 of those measures had been decided.

Finding

Union-backed sides won 33 of the 49 decided measures and lost 16. Winning campaigns received $98.4M in union money, compared with $61.3M for losing campaigns. Winning sides accounted for 62% of that spending.

Six largest union-funded measuresUnion moneyShare of campaignUnion’s side
CA Prop 15, 2020Tax commercial property for schools $35.8M65.7% Lostfailed 52–48
CA Prop 50, 2025Redraw the congressional maps $27.0M28.7% Wonpassed, about 64–36
CA Prop 55, 2016Extend the high-earner income tax $18.3M54.7% Wonpassed 62.3%
CA Prop 22, 2020Gig drivers stay contractors $18.0M94.8% Lostpassed 59%
WA I-2124, 2024Opt out of the WA Cares program $10.4M99.0% Wonrejected 55.5–44.5
CA Prop 30, 2022Tax on incomes over $2M for electric vehicles $5.3M99.2% Wonrejected 59–41

“Won” and “lost” describe the union’s side, not the measure. On three of these six (CA Prop 22, WA I-2124 and CA Prop 30), the union was campaigning against the measure, so a rejected measure is a win. Share of the campaign is union money as a proportion of everything that committee raised. Each measure links to its full background; results can also be looked up at California’s Secretary of State and Washington’s results archives.

Labor funded 94.8% of the No campaign on Proposition 22, roughly $18M. App companies outspent that campaign about ten to one, and the measure passed with 59%. Proposition 15 received the largest union contribution total in the dataset, $35.8M, or two-thirds of its campaign's funding. It failed by four points.

Bills introduced

Funded legislators sponsored more pro-labor bills

We compared legislators who received union contributions with unfunded legislators of the same party in the same chamber, counting the pro-labor bills each introduced as primary sponsor.

Finding

Funded legislators are the primary sponsor of 4.2× as many pro-labor bills as their unfunded colleagues in the same party. The median gap across 55 comparisons is +9.4 points, and 26 of the 55 exceed ten points.

Funded legislators sponsored 1.44× as many bills overall and 4.17× as many pro-labor bills. In all 10 cases tested, the difference in pro-labor sponsorship exceeded the difference in overall sponsorship. General legislative activity alone did not account for the gap.

We count primary sponsors, the legislators who introduce bills. We exclude cosponsors who add their names to someone else's bill.

Bills passed

Bill passage rates were similar

Finding

Pro-labor bills authored by funded legislators passed at 57.6%, compared with 56.5% for those authored by unfunded legislators, a gap of roughly one point.

Within individual comparisons, funded legislators' passage rates averaged +5.2 points above their colleagues' for other bills and −8.8 points below for pro-labor bills. These averages differ from the pooled rates above.

Bill introduction can put a position on the record and contribute to later legislation.

Floor votes

Floor voting differed by about two points

Finding

Comparing legislators of the same party on final-passage votes, the funded ones side with labor about 1.8 points more often. Across 55 comparisons the range runs from −5.0 to +18.1.

We compare legislators within parties because Democrats and Republicans differ substantially in their labor voting records, and most union contributions go to Democrats. A comparison across parties would conflate that party difference with the funding relationship.

The difference was small relative to the gap in bill sponsorship, though a few votes can matter in a closely divided chamber.

Close elections

Close-election results varied by state

We matched union contributions to 5,361 candidates in the six states where campaign-finance records could be joined by name to certified results. We then compared outcomes in races decided by fewer than ten points.

Close-race win-rate differences by state ranged from −0.5 to +42 points

The chart shows the difference in win rates between funded and unfunded candidates in races decided by fewer than ten points. Each state is labeled with its sample size. The largest differences occur in the smallest samples.

no difference BY STATE, LARGEST SAMPLE FIRST Arizona 304 candidates +9.1 Washington 222 candidates −0.5 California 123 candidates +16.1 Michigan 90 candidates +22.3 New York 83 candidates +31.1 Oregon 45 candidates +42.0 −10 0 +10 +20 +30 +40 percentage points more likely to win a close race →
The two largest samples Smaller samples 867 of the 5,361 candidates ran in a close race

State estimates span 42 points. Washington has the longest campaign-finance history in the comparison and provides its own certified results export. It shows little difference in close-race win rates. The three largest differences come from the three smallest samples.

The Chicago Teachers Union gave $5,487,921 to Friends of Brandon Johnson between February 2019 and January 2025, according to the Illinois State Board of Elections disclosure record. It is the largest union total to a single candidate in the file, and it falls outside the six states. Johnson, a former CTU organizer, won the Chicago mayoralty in April 2023 with 51.4%.

What is stable in all six states

Incumbents won about 96% of the time with union funding and about 94% without it. Most contributions went to candidates in seats that were not closely contested. The data does not establish whether union funding changes close-election outcomes.

Interpreting the results

The clearest legislative association was with sponsorship

For unions assessing their spending, sponsorship and passage need separate measures. Funded legislators introduced more pro-labor bills, but those bills passed at a similar rate to bills from unfunded colleagues.

The roughly two-point difference in floor voting is consistent with unions funding legislators who already share their priorities. The comparison cannot establish whether contributions changed anyone's votes.

Method

How this was built

Whose money

Form LM-2 filings from the Labor Department’s Office of Labor-Management Standards, which every union above $250,000 in annual receipts must file. The fiscal-2025 file we worked from holds 4,599 LM-2s. Locals are ranked on the dues they spent on political activity, not on their PAC. The two are legally separate pots. Federal law bars dues money from funding federal candidates.

Where it went

Campaign-finance filings from twelve states (Washington, Illinois, California, Arizona, New York, Massachusetts, Oregon, Maryland, Michigan, Ohio, Minnesota and Pennsylvania), plus the Federal Election Commission. Committees are matched to unions from the committee’s own registered name rather than the FEC’s affiliated-organization field, which is unreliable enough to label a national fund after a single local branch.

What the legislators did

Bills, primary sponsorships and recorded floor votes from LegiScan. 1,969 bills were classified by direction: 575 pro-labor, 54 anti-labor, 1,340 neutral. Civly set the direction using keyword rules and a model that reads each bill. It does not reflect any union’s stated position on any bill.

Who won

Candidate outcomes use certified returns from Washington’s own certified export and OpenElections for Arizona, California, Oregon, Michigan, and New York. Each ballot-measure outcome was checked separately and assigned a source.

The comparison

Every result compares union-funded legislators with unfunded ones of the same party in the same chamber. One comparison is one union in one state, split by party. There are 55. A candidate who ran in more than one of these elections is counted once for each. Where a state’s campaign-finance record begins later than its election results, the earlier years are dropped, because every candidate in those years would otherwise count as unfunded.

Limits

What this cannot tell you

These are associations
The data does not show that spending caused any outcome.
Funding may follow sponsorship
Unions may contribute to legislators because those legislators have sponsored pro-labor bills. The observed relationship is consistent with that explanation and does not establish that contributions produced the sponsorship.
What a win rate can’t tell you
Unions choose which measures to fund, so the two-in-three win rate reflects the measures they picked as well as the money they spent. Unions also funded both sides of the same question: the yes and no campaigns on California’s Proposition 30 in 2022 and Proposition 36 in 2024, and the two rival death-penalty measures on the 2016 ballot. On the death-penalty measures, police associations funded the opposite side from everyone else.
Geographic coverage
The twelve states were selected because their campaign-finance records were available to us. Six could be joined to certified candidate results. The sample is not random and does not describe the other thirty-eight states.
Limited coverage of spending
In these six states, 6% of union political giving ($126M of $2.04B) reaches a state legislative candidate. The rest goes to governors, mayors, city councils, judges, ballot committees and other unions’ own funds, which cannot be scored against a legislative record. Part of the $2.04B is transfers between union committees. Everything in this article describes the part of union political money that can be scored.
Bill classification
Civly classified each bill as pro-labor, anti-labor or neutral using keywords and a model. No union was consulted, and no union’s stated position enters the calculation.
Limited passage evidence
Only three union-and-state comparisons met our evidence threshold for passage: operating engineers in Washington, service employees in New York, and electrical workers in Maryland, all among Democrats. That is too few to reach a firm conclusion about the relationship between funding and bill passage. Funded legislators may introduce more ambitious pro-labor bills or face chambers less willing to pass them. The data does not test either explanation.
Civly political research

Connect campaign finance with legislative records

Civly combines federal and state campaign-finance records with bills, sponsorships, and floor votes from all fifty state legislatures. These records support its research reports, donor lists, and compliance checks.


Civly Politics Research · prepared August 13, 2026. Sources: U.S. Department of Labor LM-2 filings, the Federal Election Commission, campaign-finance filings from twelve states, LegiScan, the Washington Secretary of State’s certified results export, and OpenElections. Ballot-measure outcomes were looked up individually with a source recorded for each.

Figures reflect data available on that date. The fiscal-2025 LM-2 file continues to receive late filings, and published ballot-measure vote shares are subject to reconciliation against each state’s own certified return.

Findings describe association in observed data. They do not establish that any expenditure caused any outcome. The pro-labor or anti-labor direction assigned to each bill is Civly’s classification and does not reflect any union’s stated position. Not legal, compliance, or investment advice.